Sunday, December 30, 2012

Oh, What a Tangled Web...

The problem with a lie, as we were all taught as children, is that it will rarely remain just one lie. In a matter of any importance at all, one lie will invariably necessitate another, and then another; and so by exponents, a seemingly simple lie becomes a complex web of deceit.

This has already been well-demonstrated in the case of Patrick Bradford, falsely convicted in 1993 of the murder of Tammy Lohr. It took years to unravel and document that complex web of perjury and deception spun by Prosecutor Stan Levco and detective Guy Minnis. But even now, 20 years later, their lies continue to multiply.

Having learned of a Law and Society class at St. Louis University studying the irregularities of the case, former detective Minnis felt compelled--like a moth to the flame, it would seem--to address the class in person in a futile attempt to salvage his tattered web.

Early reports from the students on the spectacle indicate that Minnis, under cover of selective memory, theatrics, bluster, and wholesale slander of Patrick Bradford (naturally) and of his well-respected family (inexplicably), refused to answer any pertinent questions. Instead, he piled more transparent lies on top of those already exposed. It will take time to parse and research all of Minnis' diatribe, but two example follow:

                                                          Silence of the Lambs
 
 
Aside from slander, Minnis employed mostly unprovable harpoons. For example, he declared that the FBI had worked up a psychological "profile" on Patrick, dubbing him a "narcissistic monster". The problems with this one of Minnis' lies are many:
 
1.) This is not what a "profile" is. The FBI employs psychologically trained criminalists to develop a "profile" on hypothetical perpetrators based on the known characteristics of a given crime.
 
2.) Some attempt at this legitimate profiling was made, as we know from the 1992 deposition of Stanley Ford, but nothing involving a psychological disorder, and certainly nothing inolving Patrick Bradford.
 
3.) Patrick was never the subject of a psychological examination, which would have involved, at least, some kind of interview by a qualified professional. (There was, however, rigorous testing and interviewing during the pre-employment process, which marked Patrick as a stable, and desirable candidate for the EPD.)
 
4.) Minnis had already shown himself fond of the word "narcissist" in his railing email to the class in advance of his appearance. This imaginary FBI profiler sounds a great deal like Minnis himself. At any rate, he misuses the term "narcissistic".
 
In fact, this lie is not new. At least one witness reported that, during the investigation, Minnis used this story to influence her as he interviewed her. He told her he had gone to the FBI Headquarters "like in Silence of the Lambs," where profilers told him Patrick is a "pretty scary guy".
 
Nothing was beneath him then; nothing has changed.
 
                                                           The Trouble with Soot
 
Another of Minnis' new/old lies involves actual evidence: physical evidence. He claimed that no soot was found on Patrick's uniform (indicating that Patrick's account of entering the house and observing the fire at the bedroom door was fabricated). This lie has its own set of problems:
 
1.) No such test was done. The FBI report on the testing of the uniform proves that. How was it determined that there was no soot on a black uniform? (On the other hand, the FBI did test for blood and gasoline...and there was none!).
 
2.) As Minnis knows very well, the presence of soot WAS reported by witnesses.
        a. Officer Robert Weaver testified that he saw what he believed was soot on Patrick's face and smelled smoke (which is merely airborne soot) on his uniform (1042).
 
        b. Officer Ryan Rizen testified to the identical description of soot on Patrick's face (and light coloration on the knees of his uniform, consistent with Patrick's account of crawling in on the carpet). (1009, 21-22).
 
            Unlike the honest Officer Weaver, Rizen was very reluctant to confirm the soot, but he was compelled to do so by his prior deposition. He was clearly influenced before trial by Minnis/Levco.
 
3.) The trial record starkly demonstrates that Prosecutor Levco, too, was wishing that the evidence of the soot would just go away. His attempt to make that happen must be read to be believed.
 
From Levco's closing argument:
 
"I didn't hear anybody say that they smelled smoke, I think maybe Officer Weaver did but certainly if he did he was the only one; didn't smell smoke on his uniform and there wasn't anybody--Ryan Rizen said there was something about the uniform knees that was different, but you saw the uniform and nobody else said that (4063).
 
Like the Jedi mind trick, irresistible to the weak-minded.
 
How far will it go? How much more ridiculous will the lies become? Even now that the web has been irreversibly dismantled, Minnis continues to spin!


Sunday, November 11, 2012

Thou Doth Protest Too Much


It is no secret that Patrick Bradford has had the support of his family (both biological and in-laws) and friends from the very beginning. Their support of him and belief in his innocence has never wavered. To rational thinking individuals, this is a sign of character. His family, who would know him better than anyone else, continues to vocalize their support for him and attest to his innate goodness of spirit.

Yet, former Detective Guy Minnis does not see it quite that way. When a Law and Society class at St. Louis University studying the Bradford case decided to email Minnis for his perspective, they received a fiery and demeaning response about Bradford's character. He didn't stop there. He intends to drive the 3 hours on Nov. 28th, possibly with the entire "team" in tow (Levco, Storey, et al.) to try and persuade this group of students that their support of Bradford is misplaced. This is certainly reason enough to take pause and question his motivations. And there is more.

Not only does he intend to speak to the class, his correspondence with the professor of that class indicated that he had been following the student/class blog and other social media outlets where the case was objectively dissected with the help of Bradford's daughter Amy. In Minnis' fiery onslaught against Bradford's character he suggests primarily: that he (Patrick) is a narcissist and manipulator who, by manipulating his family has done almost as much harm to them as by murdering Tammy *Not in those kind of words. And much more.*

This sort of response reveals a lot about Det. Minnis. Is he so blind that he cannot see the flashing lights? Family support is not indicative of manipulation. The accusation that Patrick Bradford has been skillfully manipulating his entire extended family for 20 years from behind the walls of his prison cell is nothing short of ridiculous. It is very clear to (most) people that Patrick has the support of his family because he was unjustly accused and convicted of a heinous crime that they believe him incapable of committing--not simply because of his good nature but because the facts support his innocence.

Minnis' determination to defend his position--particularly to a group of college kids in Missouri-- 20 years later tells a startling truth about his conscience. Not only can he not put this conviction to bed, he feels the need to do some damage control. Methinks he doth protest too much! What Minnis should consider is this: The truth can't be buried or explained away. It is here to stay and so is Bradford's support.

 

UPDATE

The Indiana Court of Appeals has granted the Attorney General a final extension to file its Brief of Appelee. The new deadline is Nov. 15, 2012. Following that, Public Defender Hope Fey will have until Dec. 3 to file a Reply Brief, but may request one further extension. After the Reply Brief is filed, the pleadings will be closed. The Court of Appeals will have an undetermined amount of time to make a decision.

Thursday, September 20, 2012

WE WILL APPEAL!

The next phase in the 20+ year fight for Truth and Justice for Tammy Lohr and Patrick Bradford came on August 31,2012.

Deputy Public Defender Hope Fey filed the Brief of Appellant for Patrick Bradford in the Court of Appeals of Indiana. This is the first step in the process of appealing the decision of Judge Carl Heldt, denying Post-Conviction relief of March 12 ,2012.

The State's response, the Brief of Appellee, is due within 30 days of this filing, although they will likely ask for one extension of time. When that Brief is filed, Ms. Fey will file a Reply brief.

The recent decisions of the Indiana Supreme Court and the Court of Appeals of Indiana in the case of Bunch vs. State, 964 N.E. 2nd 274 (Ind. Ct. App. 2012), trans.denied, suggest that Indiana is finally ready to give science its proper place in the determination of Truth in the legal process. But even this beginning was so long in coming that there is no certainty that Science and Truth will prevail here.

Pray for Truth and pray for Justice for Tammy and Patrick.

**The brief is not yet displayed on the Indiana Court of Appeals site, but keep your eye on it (Case No. 82A01-1203-129)








(To those who have voiced the comments "Just give up already and serve your sentence." To you we say --It's hard to beat someone who never gives up.--  We will never stop.)

Thursday, August 30, 2012

UPDATE

Very shortly after Patrick Bradford's Petition for Post-Conviction Relief was denied, the Indiana Court of Appeals reversed the conviction of one Kristine Bunch in an arson case with several very similar issues. The Court found that new, reliable scientific findings and methods should qualify as newly discovered evidence where older, debunked methods had contributed to a conviction.

Although it sounds like common sense, this was a groundbreaking decision in Indiana, where similar arguments have routinely been rejected, as Judge Carl Heldt demonstrated just a week earlier in Patrick's case. And so there was reason for hope, because the Bunch case set a valuable precedent for Patrick's appeal.

However, precisely because the new decision was groundbreaking, that hope was tempered with a strong likelihood that it would be reversed by the Indiana Supreme Court. But that high Court, with a new Chief Justice, has chosen to let the precedent stand, refusing even to hear the State Attorney General's argument against it (Petition for Transfer: Denied).

Patrick's appeal brief will be filed by September 12, 2012, after which the State will file its answer, and Patrick will be allowed a Response. There is no way to know how long a final decision will take.

Thursday, August 2, 2012

A Sad Day in History

In light of today's date--August 2, 2012-- I feel that an original post is necessary.

20 years ago today, a bright young woman (not much younger than myself), had every dream and opportunity ripped from her by force. It is so undeniably tragic that the world was denied her presence. Her family and friends have suffered, and countless others have been victimized as a result of her murder.

Some may be confused by the statement "others have been victimized by her murder". The truth is, whether you want to acknowledge it or not, the wrong man was prosecuted and convicted for this crime. It is uncomfortable to think that we may have been wrong. It is much easier to believe the media's distorted version. I mean, no one wants to be wrong...especially about something so pressing. Because of the wrongful conviction of Patrick Bradford for the murder of Tammy Lohr, a long list of people have been victimized. Tammy's family, who was exploited and led to believe that those entrusted to seek justice for their beloved were actually taking the responsibility seriously...They have been denied justice, blindly at that! Patrick's family endured (and still do on occasion) public humiliation. They watched as a beloved son, husband, father, brother, uncle, friend was wrenched from them, defamed, and thrust into a living hell for a crime he did not commit; a crime the facts prove him innocent of. Last but not least, the public is a victim. We naturally rely on investigators and other elected officials to pursue justice honestly and responsibly. Yet, those who handled this particular case abused our trust. They lied to us and manipulated us by means of the media...playing us for fools, all for the sake of bolstering their careers. It is nothing short of shameful.

It astounds me how many people think they KNOW something about this particular case. After scanning comments posted on Courier & Press articles I've had the privilege of seeing just how ignorant--and I mean that in the least offensive way possible--the public is about the real meat and potatoes of this case. They are convinced that there was "overwhelming evidence" against Patrick Bradford. If you've spent even 2 minutes reading the case files you can see there is actually no evidence. At all. No blood spatter, fingerprint, eye witness, confession, motive, hair, fiber, gasoline trace..nothing. So, to clear the record I've decided to post exactly what the State alleged, in all of its absurdity. I've also included highlights of Patrick Bradford's defense and some closing arguments. Happy reading. May you be enlightened and hopefully as enraged as those of us who have had the pleasure of knowing the ugly truth all along.



THE TRIAL



                The murder/arson trial of Patrick Bradford in 1993 lasted about 3 weeks. The evidence against him was 100% circumstantial: no eye witness to the crimes and no physical evidence linking Patrick to the crimes.

                Prosecutor Stan Levco presented a case based almost entirely on perjured and incompetent testimony.

                The theory of the State’s case was that Patrick began his patrol shift behaving normally, gassed up at approximately 11:00 PM, arrived at Tammy Lohr’s (victim) house halfway across town at virtually the same time, became enraged over some unknown thing, stabbed her to death (21 wounds), performed elaborate impromptu crime scene staging (disabling outside telephone lines, rifling and ransacking, cutting out a window screen, propping open the window and placing a ladder underneath), as well as removing all traces of blood, all within about 20 minutes. He then allegedly made a false local wanted check on the radio at 11:27, was seen patrolling across town at 11:45, and behaved normally and performed exemplary throughout a busy night shift.

                The theory further entailed that Patrick returned to the scene at 6:35 AM, walked casually into the house, went out the back to retrieve a gas can, relocked and latched the back doors, went down into the basement to find and switch off the power breaker specific to the bedroom, came back upstairs and caught and killed Tammy’s dog, doused the body, bed, and floor with gasoline without leaving a trace on his clothes, ignited the gas and closed the bedroom door and emerged from the house with a huge column of smoke already visible from blocks away, all within 20-30 seconds before calling for help on his radio.

                Thereafter and without exception his behavior was appropriate to the circumstances in the opinions of many civilian and law enforcement witnesses.





THE STATE’S CASE



                The features of the prosecution most relevant to the crimes alleged were:



                The State led with technical data, radio logs, and supporting witnesses, establishing beyond any doubt—down to seconds—the times at issue:

                Patrick went on his shift shortly before 11:00 PM and went to fuel his car. He called for a local wanted check on a subject at 11:27. His first dispatched run was at 12:11 AM. After his shift ended, he arrived at Tammy’s house just before 6:35, and almost immediately reported the fire on his radio.

                Several witnesses testified that they did not see smoke in the area before Patrick’s arrival. Several police officers testified to their observations as they arrived to assist; their accounts were consistent with Patrick’s, and their descriptions of his demeanor were consistent with innocence.

                Some of the officers reported that Patrick had told them that Tammy was inside the burning house.

                Crime scene technicians (aided by the FBI) could find no physical link between Patrick and the crimes (hair, fingerprint, DNA, blood, fiber, gasoline), but they also offered the opinion that they cut screen, open window, and disabled phone lines were staged. This was supported only by Cpl. Stan Ford’s demonstration, standing the inside of a mocked-up window, following the existing cut line with an imaginary knife—he admitted upon cross examination that the same could have been done from the outside.

                A forensic pathologist testified that Tammy could have died as much as 24 hours before the crime was discovered--despite the time he listed on her death certificate which placed her death at 5 hours but more likely 2 hours before discovery (based on the fresh appearance of the pancreas and other organs).

                Two fire investigators opined that the fire must have begun approximately at the time of Patrick’s arrival.

                A fireman swore that, upon entering, he found the door closed and no flames discernible, contrary to Patrick’s statement that he could see flames in the bedroom (See “Perjury”, Capt. Baugh).

                Several witnesses described seeing police cars in Tammy’s driveway at widely different times and on different shifts--which actually indicates that she was involved with other police officers. Strangely, they were never identified.

                Another witness reported a recovered memory (after three days of media reports) of seeing a police car in Tammy’s driveway at 11:00 PM on the night before the discovery of the crime (See “Perjury”: Elizabeth Spradley).

                A local thug denied having been out where Patrick claimed to have seen him at 11:27, when he called dispatch for a local wanted check (see “Perjury”: George Russell).

                Two officers swore that Patrick arrived late, and with smoking brakes, to his first run at 12:11 AM, suggesting that he had left from the crime scene across town (See “Perjury”: Donald Erk, Jr. and Robert Hahn).

                The lead detective described a timing test which, he claimed, revealed a 20 second window of unaccounted-for time after Patrick’s arrival at the scene at 6:35 AM.

                The State also called the most likely suspect—Finis Vincent—to clear himself. An avowed enemy of Tammy’s, on whom she had filed a police report for stalking, swore that he had been at home all night until after 7:00 AM. His wife corroborated this, although their stories were contradictory.



THE DEFENSE



                The Defense case consisted primarily of reactions the allegations of the State.  A long list of witnesses established Patrick’s alibi from 12:40 AM through the end of his shift, which forced the State to its 20 minute window for the murder and 20 second window for the arson.

                The many alibi witnesses confirmed both that Patrick was where he had claimed to be and also that his demeanor was normal and his duty performance was admirable throughout the night. A neighbor reported that Tammy’s bedroom light was on at 12:30 AM, proving both that somebody was alive in the house after the State alleges Tammy was killed, within Patrick’s established alibi, and that a trip to the basement breaker box must be figured into the 20 second arson window in the State’s theory.

                A traffic engineer calculated that Patrick had almost certainly encountered a red light just before reaching Tammy’s house in the morning, eliminating altogether the already fantastic 20 second opportunity for arson.

                A newspaper carrier testified that he had smelled smoke just outside Tammy’s bedroom window several minutes before Patrick’s arrival.

                A private fire expert testified quite inexpertly that the fire must have been burning well before Patrick’s arrival. (See “Science: Junk Science” Barker Davie).

                Several witnesses who had passed by the house between 11:00 and 11:30 PM testified that they did not see a police car in the driveway.

                There was a day and a half of testimony and cross examination of Patrick Bradford, which revealed little beyond his prior statements and no significant irregularities.





CLOSING ARGUMENTS



                The closing arguments were telling: Prosecutor Stan Levco maintained that the State’s theory had been proven, despite the admitted unlikelihood, self-contradicted key witnesses, and virtually impossible windows of opportunity. At least ten times during his summation, he used phrases like “I’m not saying I can prove this, but…”.



                For the Defense, attorney Terry Noffsinger concentrated primarily on the extreme unlikelihood (reasonable doubt) of the timing aspects of the State’s theory and the fact that all of the State’s key witnesses had given directly contradictory prior statements.



                The Jury deliberated for three days before delivering a verdict of guilty.